Return to Islam Watch main site

Islam Watch

Telling the truth about Islam: Islam under scrutiny by ex-Muslims
Welcome to Islam Watch Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

A Letter from an Animal - Shabana Muhammad

Last post 05-26-2007, 10:53 AM by kope. 4 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  10-15-2006, 1:42 AM 1244

    A Letter from an Animal - Shabana Muhammad

    A Letter from an Animal  [15 October, 2006]
    Editor,
    Islam-watch.org
  •  10-15-2006, 1:46 AM 1245 in reply to 1244

    Re: A Letter from an Animal - Shabana Muhammad

    Shabana:
    [There is one more reason why sharia is a tough law. As we Muslims are animals, we don't have self-control like human beings. If a girl is walking naked on the streets, a kafir may look at her curiously but may not jump on her. But our Muslim men will no be able to control themselves and it is a sure bet that the girl will be raped. Even by seeing the hands, legs or face of a woman, a Muslim man gets sexually aroused.]

    Dear Shabana,

    Let me acknowledge that you are one of my favorite writers. You have very original and penetrative thoughts. Yet, I have disagreed with your aim to denigrate the good name of 'animals' time and again.

    Just consider the quoted section from your latest article. When a young girl walk on the street naked, definitely Muslims will, with much higher frequency, jump on her and rape her. But non-Muslim homo sapiens will also do the same albeit in lower frequency.

    But consider a dog or any other animal. Although male dogs have a round-the-year urge to copulate, he will wait until the mating season for the female dogs arrive and wait for his chances. Female dogs walk around naked all round the year, mix with the males openly and play with them but the male dog would never sexually assult her until she gives the mating signal. This applies to all animals saveth homo sapiens.

    Not only in sex, in most other aspect of life, animals on an average show a more civilzed and responsible behavior than the homo sapiens in general. Hence, I have stopped using terms like animal, beast, dog and monster etc that are in age-old usage to define numerous human failings. It's OK to use them had they been deserving but no beasts, dogs and non-human beings deserve them. To my mind, there is no better way to define a human failing by saying 'you are a
    bloody man'. I am quite in favor of giving the term man/homo sapiens a darogatory color, which it derserves most.

    MA Khan
    Editor, islam-watch.org
    --------------------------


    Editor,
    Islam-watch.org
  •  10-15-2006, 1:48 AM 1246 in reply to 1245

    Addendum by Mohammad Asghar

    A good comment, indeed.

    As some one has said: Comparing Muslims with the animals is an insult to the animals.

    Muslims cannot be compared with any living being. Made inanimate by their religious doctrines, they are unique to themselves.

    - Mohammad Asghar


    Editor,
    Islam-watch.org
  •  05-26-2007, 4:06 AM 4370 in reply to 1244

    Re: A Letter from an Animal - Shabana Muhammad

    "IGNORANCE is FUTILE" My sister.

    Get acquainted with Knowledge and understand Islam is a Fair and Just religion, and to Judge Islam solely on the basis of some "muslims'" actions is very naive.

    Use you own mind, that's what Allah SWT gave you!  Do what is required by Allah SWT and you will be Successful here, in this world, and after, in the next.

    And in future, don't use derogatory statements about Islam without any basis.

    Jazak'Allah khair.

    Wa'Salaam.

  •  05-26-2007, 10:53 AM 4371 in reply to 1245

    Re: A Letter from an Animal - Shabana Muhammad

    Shabana:
    [There is one more reason why sharia is a tough law. As we Muslims are animals, we don't have self-control like human beings. If a girl is walking naked on the streets, a kafir may look at her curiously but may not jump on her.

     then why are cases of sexual harassment in the workplace on the news media every day?

    a sample of those accused of sexual harassment, in the last few years in america, includes: Navy officers, Managers, University professors, Senators, Supreme Court Justices, and the President of the United States!

    What's Wrong With This Outfit, Mom?

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/11/18/AR2005111801778.html
    http://tinyurl.com/ex83c

    By Patricia Dalton
    Sunday, November 20, 2005; B01

    I heard about it in my kitchen before I read about it in the newspaper:
    After visiting the expanded Tysons Corner Center this fall, my
    23-year-old daughter said, "You won't believe how weird Victoria's
    Secret's gotten: It's all red and black with a bunch of mannequins that
    look like porn stars."

    Women once complained about being reduced to sex objects. Now, their
    daughters are volunteering to be sex objects.

    Patricia Dalton is a clinical psychologist in private practice in
    Washington.

    =======================

    i am a radical muslim please read my blog read how islam will win the
    clash of civilization.
    http://www.xanga.com/hfghj23458654fgha

View as RSS news feed in XML
Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems