Islam
Under Scrutiny by Ex-Muslims
Should The Islamic World Apologize For Slavery?; Part 3
03 Apr, 2007
The white slavery of the Barbary corsairs ended only when the
perpetrators were subjected to the threat of the firepower of a
military assault. Though xebecs no longer captured Western ships
and their crews, slavery still continued. James Richardson
(1809-1851) was a British traveler and diplomat. He
noted
in 1850 that in Tripoli and Tunis, caravans were
continually arriving with new black slaves for their Muslim
masters. As he followed the slave routes southward, he saw
numerous small piles of stones, which he was told were grave
markers left by women slaves for their children who had died on
the caravan journey.
Richardson would later discover in Zinder, Niger, that many of
the black slaves transported to the Barbary states were themselves
Muslim. In
"Narrative of a Mission to Central Africa" (Ch 12)
he wrote: "I am very sorry to hear of the iniquitous manner in
which slaves are captured for the supply of the north at this
present time. It appears that, now all these populations are
Muslims, it is difficult to get up the war-cry of "Kafers!" -
"Infidels!" What is then done? The sultan of a province foments a
quarrel with a town or village belonging to himself, and then goes
out and carries off all the people into slavery."
Richardson also traveled to Morocco, which was ruled by Moulay
Ismail's descendant, Moulay Abderrahmane (sultan from 1822 to
1859). Richardson wrote that in one particular year, 10,000 black
slaves had been imported into Morocco, but the usual annual
traffic was about half that number. He
wrote: "No Jew or Christian is permitted to buy or
hold a slave in this country. Government possesses many slaves,
and people hire them out by the day from the authorities. The
ordinary price of a good slave is eighty dollars. Boys, at the age
of nine or ten years, sell the best; female slaves do not fetch so
much as male slaves, unless of extraordinary beauty."
In central and east Africa, the medical missionary David
Livingstone (1813 - 1873) would witness at first hand the abuses
of the Muslim slave trade. On his second journey to the interior,
he encountered a Muslim slave caravan in Malawi, a region he
described as where "Satan has his Seat". He wrote that "two of the
women had been shot the day before for attempting to untie the
thongs. One woman had her infant's brains knocked out because she
could not carry her load and a man was dispatched with an axe
because he had broken down with fatigue."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cf728/cf7282abd64db956c5f5aa881fea2d114eb186ec" alt=""
One Muslim slave trader,
Tippu Tip
(Hemedi bin Muhammad el Marjebi) was born in Zanzibar in 1837,
himself the grandson of an African slave. He established a base
west of Lake Tanganyika, helped by Africans of the Nyamwezi and
Msiri tribes, and thence exported slaves to Stonetown for sale. In
1873, the British threatened to bombard Zanzibar, and its slave
trade was officially ended. The Arab slave trade had been draining
Africa since the 9th century.
Traditionally, Islam has never condemned slavery. As
Murray Gordon states of traditional Arab scholars;
"No moral opprobrium has clung to slavery since it was sanctioned
by the Koran and enjoyed an undisputed place in Arab society."
According to
Bernard
Lewis, author of
Race and Slavery in the Middle East: "Black slaves
were brought into the Islamic world by a number of routes - from
West Africa across the Sahara to Morocco and Tunisia, from Chad
across the desert to Libya, from East Africa down the Nile to
Egypt, and across the Red Sea and Indian Ocean to Arabia and the
Persian Gulf. Turkish slaves from the steppe-lands were marketed
in Samarkand and other Muslim Central Asian cities and from there
exported to Iran, the Fertile Crescent, and beyond. Caucasians, of
increasing importance in the later centuries, were brought from
the land bridge between the Black Sea and the Caspian and were
marketed mainly in Aleppo and Mosul."
Slavery is advocated in the Koran. Though Mohammed states that
freeing slaves gains merit, he made no prohibitions against
acquiring slaves. Women and girl slaves could be gained as "booty"
in raids. Sura 33, verse 50 states: "Prophet, we have made lawful
for you.... the slave-girls whom God has given you as
booty." These could be raped at will by Muslims who in no way
contradicted the Koran - Suras 23:1 and 70:22 state that it is
lawful to have sex with slave girls. The Hadiths are filled with
references to slaves owned by Mohammed and his associates. In
one Hadith Mohammed intervened to reverse one man's
emancipation of six slaves. By casting lots, Mohammed denied
freedom to four of them.
With such a poor example set by the founder of Islam, it is no
wonder that Muslim countries were slow to forbid slavery. The
Ottoman Empire abolished slavery in stages, beginning in 1847,
when trading in slaves was banned in the Persian Gulf. Women
slaves were still sold in the Ottoman Empire as late as
1908. Slavery continued after the Ottoman Empire
was crushed in 1924. Qatar did not abolish slavery until
1952. Yemen and Saudi Arabia abolished slavery in 1962, and
Mauritania did not officially abolish slavery until 1980.
In 1990, an Islamic "declaration of human rights" was signed in
Cairo, even though "freedoms" are only allowed if
they do not contradict Sharia law. Article 11 a of the declaration
reads: "Human beings are born free, and no one has the right to
enslave, humiliate, oppress or exploit them, and there can be no
subjugation but to God the Most-High."
Despite this lame attempt to declare rights for all, Muslim
slavery continued, following the tradition of Islam's founder. Mauritania
had practiced slavery for centuries, particularly when it was part
of the empire of Moorish rulers such as Moulay Ismail.
Declarations of Islamic human rights have had little influence
here, where Arab elites still believe they have the right to
enslave Africans.
The Atlantic slave trade exacted a high death toll, but in the
West, male slaves were encouraged to reproduce. In the Islamic
world, though Islam forbids castration, black male slaves were
frequently subjected to this brutal operation. A. B. Wylde, a
British consul in Egypt,
noted in the 1880s that there were 500 eunuchs in
Cairo. He believed that 199 out of 200 people who were castrated
did not survive, and suggested that the 500 Cairo eunuchs
represented "100,000 Soudanese" who had been killed. Whyte was
over-estimating the death-rate, but certainly more people
subjected to the operation died than survived. Eunuchs could gain
status in Muslim societies, but their rights to procreate had been
denied. As late as
1903 the Ottoman ruling family owned 194 eunuchs,
and 35 of these had positions of "seniority".
Islamic apologists make claims that Islam has no racism, even
though Mohammed himself
said that an Ethiopian slave could have a head that
"looks like a raisin". According to
Bernard Lewis (page 38) the Arab philosopher Ibn
Khaldun (1332 - 1406) wrote: "The only people who accept slavery
are the Negroes, owing to their low degree of humanity and their
proximity to the animal stage."
Such attitudes still exist in Mauritania and also Sudan, where
Arab elites enslave black people from the Dinka and the Shilluk
tribes who live in southern Sudan. Since
1983
when the northern government engaged in a war with the south of
Sudan, slavery cases proliferated. Simon
Deng had been a Shilluk child slave, abducted to
live in northern Sudan by an Arab. In May 2006 he went on a
fact-finding mission to southern Sudan. He said that "villages are
still being burnt, women are still being raped, and people are
being sold into slavery." Mr. Deng now lives as a US citizen in
New York.
Another Sudanese-born black man who is now a US citizen is
Francis Bok. He came from a Catholic family in a
Dinka village. In 1986, when aged seven, he was
abducted by Arabs from the north who decapitated
adults at a local market and stole the children. For ten years Mr.
Bok was a slave in a Muslim household - forced to convert to Islam
- until he ran away. Some Dinka slaves who do not convert to Islam
have had their
Achilles
tendons cut.
In
2000, a UNICEF representative estimated that 5,000
to 10,000 children were still slaves in Sudan. The Dinka Committee
in 2001 claimed that 14,000 children have been abducted since
1983. In Sudan, as elsewhere, child slaves are subjected to
cruel punishments.
In
February 2006 as part of the Sudanese government's
peace deal with the south, initiated by the late John Garang with
US assistance, 163 former slaves were repatriated back to the
south. Not all slaves are children. One, Abuk Ater, was already a
married adult when she was abducted by an Arab militia. She was
also raped. For 20 years she endured slavery until being
repatriated.
In Mauritania, though some black Moors own slaves,
racism is also involved in Muslim slavery. In
1987, a purge took place on black officers in the
police and army. In 1989, 60,000 blacks were deported into Senegal
at gunpoint. Many of the slaves in Mauritania are born into
slavery.
One male slave told the
BBC
in 2004: "I don't know how I became a slave. I was just born
one. My family were slaves. We did all the hard work for our
master and all we received in return was beatings."
Though slavery has been officially illegal in Mauritania since
1981, no real punishments were enacted upon slave-owners, allowing
the trade to flourish It was only in 2003 that owning a slave was
made punishable with a fine or prison sentence. A year later, no
one had been convicted under this law, and the slavery was allowed
to continue.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b619e/b619efef3e46dce6f4c0470890dca75cc5c84e64" alt=""
The notion of a Muslim man being sanctioned by the Koran to rape
his female slaves still has echoes in the way guest workers are
treated in Saudi Arabia. Though beyond the scope of this article,
I urge you to read the
harrowing account by a Filipino woman I know, who
became a virtual slave to her Saudi employer, an imam who
repeatedly raped her. Similarly, the trade in young children,
abducted or bought in
Pakistan and
Bangladesh,
who became camel-jockeys in the United Arab Emirates, is an
example of modern Muslim slavery.
The archbishops in Britain may apologize for slavery, as may the
US states of Virginia and Maryland. But is any representative of
Islam prepared to apologize for 14 centuries of slavery? In
2003, it was revealed that a Saudi Sheik, Saleh Al-Fawzan,
said: "Slavery is a part of Islam. Slavery is part of jihad, and
jihad will remain as long there is Islam."
The Sheikh, who belongs to the Council of Religious Edicts and
Research and is an imam in Riyadh, also authored Saudi textbooks
which were sent to Saudi-funded schools around the world,
including the United States.
Slavery is intrinsically a part of Islam, and to deny it is to
contradict the supposed wisdom of Mohammed, the founder of
Islam. Much as I would love to see the luminaries of CAIR
apologize for Islam's long history of slavery and subjugation, I
think that day will be a long time coming. For many of Islam's
public representatives, being Muslim means never having to say
you're sorry.
Adrian Morgan is a
British based writer and artist who has written for
Western Resistance since its inception. He also writes for
Family Security Matters,
Spero News and
Faithfreedom.org.