A Guide to the Qur’anic Contradictions, Part 7
14 Feb, 2009
Sura 23: al-Muminun (The Believers)
23:14
Sperm is transformed into a clot of congealed blood, then the
fetus becomes a lump, then bones, then Allah clothes bones with
flesh, then into another creature; Allah is the best of creators.
Contradiction:
39:62 says Allah is the only creator.
23:15
Every human must die.
Contradiction:
4:157 says Jesus did not die, Allah took him up.
23:101-102
There will be no more relationship when the trumpet is sounded;
no question. Allah will use a balance to judge people. Those with
heavy balance (good deeds) will be successful (they will be in
Islamic Paradise).
Contradiction:
52:25 says the believers will chit-chat with one another.
Contradiction:
37:27 say the unbelievers will question one another.
Sura 24: al-Nur (Light)
24:2
Punishment for adultery or fornication (both men and women) is
one hundred lashes in front of the believers; show no mercy to
them.
Contradiction:
4:15 says life-term house confinement for women.
24:5
False accusers can give evidence, if they repent, and if they
are forgiven.
Contradiction:
24:4, 24:23 say no forgiveness towards the slanderers of chaste
women.
24:23
Grievous penalty and curse are for those who slander a chaste
woman (i.e., no forgiveness for slanderer of chaste women).
Contradiction:
24:5 says Allah allows forgiveness towards the slanderers of chaste
women if the slanderers repent.
Sura 25: al-Furqan (The Criterion)
25:20
All the apostles sent by Allah before Muhammad were ordinary men
too; they ate food and roamed markets; Allah tests some apostles, so
Muhammad must bear with patience.
Contradiction:
27:82 says Allah also sends a beast as a messenger.
Contradiction:
35:1 says Allah sends angels with wings as messengers.
Contradiction:
6:130, 11:69, 11:77, 22:75 say Allah sends jinns and angels as
messengers.
Contradiction:
11:69-70, 51:24–28 say the angel-messengers sent to Abraham did not
eat food.
25:32
The disbelievers question why Allah did not send the ENTIRE
Qur’an. The Qur’an is revealed slowly, in parts, in well-arranged
stages, so that Muhammad could memorize.
Contradiction:
2:185, 3:3, 12:111, 16:89, 43:4, 97:1 indicate Allah sent the ENTIRE
Qur’an in one night.
25:35
Allah sent Moses the Book (Torah—Jalalyn) and made his brother
Aaron, his assistant (minister).
Contradiction:
19:53 says Allah made Aaron a prophet.
Contradiction:
26:13 says Moses requested Allah that Aaron be made his helper.
25:51
If Allah willed, He could have sent apostles to every nation,
but He didn’t.
Contradiction:
10:47, 16:36 say Allah sent separate messengers to each nation.
25:59
Allah created the heavens (first) and (then) the earth and
(then) all things in between in six days; then He rose on His
Throne.
Contradiction:
41:9-12 says Allah created the heavens and the earth in eight days.
Contradiction:
2:117 says Allah creates instantly.
Sura 26: al-Shuaraa (The Poets)
26:13
In the presence of Pharaoh, Moses was scared to speak alone; he
requested Allah that Aaron (his brother) be with him (appoint Aaron
as a prophet, instead of Moses—Maududi
translation.)
Contradiction:
20:29-32, 25:35 say Allah made Aaron a Minister/partner of Moses.
26:51
Pharaoh’s magicians declared their faith in Allah (i.e., they
became Muslims) and sought His forgiveness. (They were the first
among the Egyptians to believe in Islam; so Pharaoh killed them all—ibn Kathir)
Contradiction:
2:131 says Abraham was the first Muslim.
Contradiction:
2:37 says Adam was the first Muslim.
Contradiction:
6:14 says Muhammad was the first Muslim.
Contradiction:
7:143 says Moses was the first Muslim.
26:66
Allah drowned the Pharaoh and his army.
Contradiction:
10:92 says Allah forgave and saved Pharaoh.
26:157
Salih’s people killed the she-camel, they became repentant.
Contradiction:
54:29 says one person killed the she-camel.
26:167
Unless he stopped preaching, Lot’s people threatened to banish
him.
Contradiction:
29:29 says Lot’s people wanted Lot to bring upon them the wrath of
Allah.
26:170-171
Allah saved Lot, and all his followers, except an old woman.
Contradiction:
7:83 says Allah saved Lot’s people except Lot’s wife.
Sura 27: al-Naml (The Ants)
27:56
Lot’s people wanted to banish him from their town (Lot and his
two daughters: Za'ura and Raytha—ibn Abbas.)
Contradiction:
29:29 says Lot’s people wanted Lot to bring upon them the wrath of
Allah.
27:82
Allah will create a beast from earth to talk to the unbelievers
after they have been punished (Allah might consider sending a beast
as a messenger to humans. The beast will come with the mast of
Moses—ibn Abbas. The beast will preach in Arabic—Jalalyn)
Contradiction:
12:109, 21:7-8, 25:20-21 say Allah sends only men as messengers.
Contradiction:
35:1 says Allah sends angels with wings as messengers.
Contradiction:
6:130; 11:69, 11:77, 22:75 say Allah sends jinns and angels as
messengers.
Sura 28: al-Qasas (The Narration)
28:33-34
Moses was afraid of being punished by Pharaoh for killing an
Egyptian; he was reluctant to face Pharaoh, and sought Allah’s
permission to bring along with him his brother Aaron.
Contradiction:
26:13 says Moses requested Allah to make Aaron a prophet instead of
him.
28:35
Allah agreed to appoint Aaron, Moses’ brother, to be his
assistant, and assured Moses’ victory against the Pharaoh.
Contradiction:
19:53, 26:13 says say Allah made Aaron a prophet.
28:38
Pharaoh said he was the God, and ordered his Minister, Haman, to
build a lofty tower to have a look at Moses’ Allah.
Contradiction:
7:127 says Pharaoh’s people worshipped many gods
28:40
Allah flung Pharaoh and his soldiers into the sea (Allah drowned
them in the sea in a single morning, and not one of them was left—ibn Kathir).
Contradiction:
10:92 says Allah saved Pharaoh.
28:46
Before Muhammad, Allah did not send any messengers to the
Arabs.
Contradiction:
10:47, 16:35-36, 35:24 say Allah sent messengers to every people.
28:49
Allah challenged if the unbelievers could produce a book better
than the two other books (Moses and Aaron as well as the Torah and
the Qur’an—ibn Kathir) then Muhammad would have followed that book.
Contradiction:
2:23, 10:38 say Allah challenged the unbelievers to produce one Sura
similar to the Qur’an.
Contradiction:
11:13 says Allah challenged the unbelievers to compose ten Suras
similar to the Qur’an.
Contradiction: in
17:88 Allah challenged the entire mankind and the jinni to produce
the entire Qur’an.
Contradiction:
52:34 says Allah challenged the unbelievers to compose a book
similar to the entire Qur’an.
28:58
Allah destroyed many populations; rendered many lands into
deserts, and then Allah became the heir (inherited) of those lands.
Contradiction:
2:116, 3:189, 20:6, 21:19, 57:2 say Allah is the owner of all things
in heavens and on earth, under soil and the things in space between
them.
| If you like this essay: |
Stumble it
 |
digg it |
Name: Mad Mo
Date: Friday February 13, 2009
Time: 22:28:29 -0500
Comment
That is pisslam and Satanic Verses for you. The muslims must be defended against islam.
Name: stop brain washing
Date: Friday February 13, 2009
Time: 22:54:36 -0500
Comment
again i say that this site is mainly depend on 1_take part of the quran and leave the other and this not accepted. 2_adding some words to the quranic verse to get his intended propaganda in some verses. 3_use arabic names and the site claim that the admins re ex_muslim and this is fake too and using arab names wont support ur propganda. 4_the site show how the admins think with ahtered aginst the other relegion and the site mix. politics in relegion to get his intended propaganda. 5_i added some comments which were in good way and accepted and the site del. them or hide them i cannt find them now. 6_the translation of quran in the site the author mix. some words which renot in quran. and finnaly i advice all non_muslims not to follow the media and the articles that not qualified ..and any one wanna to know about islam i advice him to read the quran and do his own search and dont follow liars and cheaters like whom made that site and actually itis not logic even for non_muslims to allow any one to cheat them even if he was non_muslim too ..b/c cheating isnot accepted ok..and we all see that islam spreeding dailly although all this propaganda aginst it..and inshallah all lairs and cheaters will gain nothing of their propaganda aginst islam.. and although i dont know english alot but i think u get wut i mean ..Stop hatered..Stop brain washing..
Name: To above
Date: Friday February 13, 2009
Time: 23:02:19 -0500
Comment
first of all we are not particularly proud of being ex-muslims. personally I feel ashamed of ever having being a muslim. secondly islam is a political cult, hence the question of seperating religion and politics in the islamic context does not arise. if you think this is a propaganda site, don't come here, you were not invited. If you want to stop brainwashing and hatred tell that to the 1.3 billion muslims who wish to kill us and the rest of humanity. Leave islam is you wish to stop this ugly genocide done by muslims. In the end, if you are still a muslim, then shame on you.
Name: Ibrahim
Date: Friday February 13, 2009
Time: 23:05:30 -0500
Comment
To the brainwashing fellow. I feel so amused when muslims talk like you do. I mean muslims are responsible for 95% of terrorism in this world and then you talk of brainwashing,lol. We don't force our beliefs on people like you muslims. we just pass on accurate information, if you dont trust us, you can consult various resources to check out the truth. I somehow feel that you are playing a very deceptive and dirty game. SO please keep your taqqiyya to yourself and don't bother to come back if you don't have the capacity to undertand or realise the truth which is ISLAM IS FALSE.
Name: HORRIBLE AND BORING ARTICLE PLS GIME SOME SPICY MASALA
Date: Saturday February 14, 2009
Time: 02:11:25 -0500
Comment
HORRIBLE AND BORING ARTICLE PLS GIME SOME SPICY MASALA : how big r the breasts of the virgins,will they be clean shaved ? will i be able to have a wine bath in jacuzi with my 72 babes all at 1 time ? can i be naked 24x7 with my babes ? these r more important questions that need to be answred.after all i am a suicide bomber for allah and need to know what is in store for me when i kill kafirs. piss be on koran,islam,muhamed,and all his jihadi followers.
Name: allah is worst creature in mohammads(let piss of humnaity be upon him) mad novell Quron
Date: Saturday February 14, 2009
Time: 07:29:22 -0500
Comment
allah is worst creature in mohammads(let piss of humnaity be upon him) mad novell Quron.
Name: Baig
Date: Saturday February 14, 2009
Time: 09:29:08 -0500
Comment
EDITOR: In case you are not aware we have already have a challenge in place for all Muslims to debate us. Here is the link http://islam-watch.org/IW/Challenge.htm. If you are confident enough, we welcome you to debate us.
Name: Quranic Contradictions
Date: Saturday February 14, 2009
Time: 10:49:12 -0500
Comment
Doesn´t the many contradiction mean that the authors of the quran drew from different sources, such as bible, talmud, apokryphals and oral traditions? There must be more than one source and one author. Meccan and Medinan sura have little in common, and there are some sura like 18 The Cave who are very unique in a way that they are obviously of christian origin.